Amanda Paul
English 104
Section #9
Instructor: Ogburn
Assignment #14
The authors of Uprooting Poverty The South African Challenge is Francis Wilson & Mamphela Ramphele.
In this I looked at Hunger and Sickness but mainly mortality rates as there were many different ways of how people died. The authors main point in the section was how there were a majority of kids that did not make to their first birthday or even to their fourth birthday. That these children are living in areas they shouldn’t and cannot survive due to improper treatment for nutrition. In the last part of the book I looked at education. The authors’ main point of education was how the children struggled in their education. Struggling with their education did not come from coming from a family in poverty but the fact that they were hungry when they got to school. Another point was that the resources the teachers had in South Africa were not enough to teach the children the way they need to be. This did not just affect colored African but also the White children in Africa.
Poverty in this book written by Wilson and Ramphele is “Poverty is partly a matter of income and partly a matter of human dignity. It is one thing to have a low income but to be treated with respect by your compatriots; it is quite another matter to have a very low income and to be harshly depreciated by more powerful compatriots” (5, David Hamburg). This is showing how poverty is defined by David Hamburg thorough the world.
From the first section of Wilson and Ramphele they talk about mortality and what I found interesting was that “…infant mortality rate, averaged somewhere between 94-125 over the period of 1984-5, was considerably worse than the national average….” (108). What I took from this is that children are not getting the right treatment when they are little and their bodies just cannot live anymore due to poor health. This age is talking before one year old. Though the last one I found interesting from Wilson and Ramphele is “...50% of all deaths in Africans and coloureds occur in the 0-4 age group…” (110). I find this important because this is showing how children in poverty of any color die young. The last quote I found interesting had to do with education form Wilson and Ramphele is that “Whilst the general level of education of the population as a whole is improving the number of young illiterates, between the ages of 10 and 25, is highly disturbing. The current estimating, based on very rough calculations is that there are between two and three million [that is illiterates]” (138). This to me is very surprising but also helps show how much children in poverty struggle and will struggle as they go on in life.
I see this source building on my reading by expanding on how countries are in poverty for example how East Berlin was in poverty. Along with Lucy Lamecks reading about poverty in Africa and how there are some rich areas but there is poverty and it is shown. This relates to my essay by expanding the thoughts of poverty especially after reading about the resources and how they are struggling. “...Africans should take control of their own destinies and develop uniquely Africa ways to generate and distribute the wealth” (352). This is just showing they have to step up and show that they are able to live well behind poverty. The last quote that goes with this is from Gandhi “Every human being has a right to live and therefore to find the wherewithal to feed himself and where necessary to clothe and house himself” (334). Saying everyone should have somewhere in life but poverty is showing there is not always room for everyone.
I plan on using this source to look at poverty in different areas. It will answer the question I am asking by showing children in Africa do not have a choice in life. They go to school try to get an education but their home life prevents it.
This source came from Alverno College. The authors are Francis Wilson and Mamphela Ramphele and they are experts. They went and did the research. There are different sections of the book but not chapters.
I see this source connecting the others by showing how poverty affects many places just not one part of the world. They will have a conversation about how children are affected by poverty and how they cannot get the education they need. Even how hard it is for the children to survive with what they have in life which is nothing.
Work Cited:
Gandhi, Mohandas. “Economic and Moral Progress.” Reading the World: Ideas That Matter. 2nd. Ed. Michael Austin. New York: Norton, 2003. Page 334. Print.
Lameck, Lucy. “Africans Are Not Poor.” Reading the World: Ideas That Matter. 2nd. Ed. Michael Austin. New York: Norton, 2003. Page 352. Print.
Wilson, Francis. Ramphele, Mamphela. “A matter of definition” Uprooting Poverty The South African Challenge. Claremont, South Africa: W.W. Norton & Company, 1989. Page 5. Print.
Wilson, Francis. Ramphele, Mamphela. “Hunger and sickness” Uprooting Poverty The South African Challenge. Claremont, South Africa: W.W. Norton & Company, 1989. Page 108-110. Print.
Wilson, Francis. Ramphele, Mamphela. “Literacy and Learning” Uprooting Poverty The South African Challenge. Claremont, South Africa: W.W. Norton & Company, 1989. Page 138. Print.